A chewy, freshly toasted bagel slathered with cream cheese is a New York breakfast institution. This satisfying morning classic is a quick, family-friendly way to start the day.
Slice each bagel in half horizontally using a serrated knife for an even cut.
Preheat your toaster or toaster oven to medium-high heat for even crisping.
Toast the bagel halves for 2–3 minutes, monitoring to ensure they are golden brown but not burnt.
Optional: Immediately spread a thin layer of unsalted butter onto the hot bagel halves to add a subtle richness and help the cream cheese melt slightly.
Generously spread 1 tablespoon of cream cheese on each warmed bagel half, ensuring an even layer for maximum flavor and creamy texture. Serve immediately for best freshness.